28 S Montgomery Avenue, Bay Shore

$1,699,999

Photo Gallery
7 Beds
4 Baths
3,864 Sqft
0 Acres
1 Garages

Welcome to 28 S. Montgomery Avenue — a distinguished Dutch Colonial set on nearly an acre of waterfront property in Bay Shore. Built in 1895, this timeless home blends historic character with thoughtful modern updates.

Featuring seven bedrooms and two full plus two half baths, it offers space for both elegant entertaining and comfortable daily living. The formal living room with fireplace and stately dining room flow to an updated kitchen, while the den includes a gas line ready for a future fireplace. Original woodwork and hardwood floors meet modern conveniences like radiant heat, new windows, a four-year-old roof, and in-ground sprinklers.

Outdoors, enjoy your heated saltwater pool, lush landscaping, and private waterfront access. A detached carriage-style garage with loft and greenhouse complete this rare offering.

Historic charm, modern comfort, and a premier Bay Shore location—this home truly has it all.

Schedule a Tour

Sat 17 Jan

Sun 18 Jan

Mon 19 Jan

Tue 20 Jan

Wed 21 Jan

Thu 22 Jan

Fri 23 Jan

Sat 24 Jan

Sun 25 Jan

Mon 26 Jan

Tue 27 Jan

Wed 28 Jan

Thu 29 Jan

Fri 30 Jan

Sat 31 Jan

Pick your availability to tour:

to
Essential Information
MLS® #919579
Price$1,699,999
Bedrooms7
Bathrooms4.00
Full Baths2
Half Baths2
Square Footage3,864
Acres0.00
Year Built1895
TypeResidential
Sub-TypeSingle Family Residence
StyleColonial
StatusActive
Community Information
Address28 S Montgomery Avenue
CityBay Shore
CountySuffolk County
StateNY
Zip Code11706
Amenities
ParkingDetached, Private
# of Garages1
ViewWater
Is WaterfrontYes
WaterfrontCanal Access, Waterfront
Has PoolYes
PoolIn Ground
Utilities

Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected

Interior
InteriorCarpet, Hardwood
Interior FeaturesEat-in Kitchen, Formal Dining
HeatingHot Water, Natural Gas
CoolingCentral Air
Has BasementYes
BasementFull, Unfinished
FireplaceYes
# of Fireplaces1
Appliances

Dishwasher, Dryer, Refrigerator, Washer

Exterior
Lot DescriptionWaterfront
WindowsSkylight(s)
ConstructionCedar
School Information
DistrictBay Shore
ElementaryBrook Avenue Elementary School
MiddleBay Shore Middle School
HighBay Shore Senior High School
Additional Information
Date ListedOctober 1st, 2025
Days on Market108
Listing Details
Listing Courtesy ofEric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
LISTING MAP

Get directions to this property:

Ask about this Property
Video Tour from Home
New
Information Copyright 2021, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.

Listing information last updated on January 17th, 2026 at 6:45am CST.